CA Tushar Makkar
56 comments
Review summary
Based on 56 comments, created with AI
Students overwhelmingly praise this teacher's teacher's experience, teaching quality, study material. Many students highlight students trust his 'correct guidance' and find his vie...
What students talk about most
Evaluation breakdown
Top Strengths
1. Clear and effective articulation
2. Provides correct guidance and realistic perspectives
3. Acknowledges the importance of hard work and investment
Areas to Improve
1. Address concerns about the CA course's relevance and value in the current industry landscape
2. Counter perceptions of being part of a 'coaching mafia' or over-promising career outcomes
3. Actively address and mitigate the issue of CAs exploiting students
What students love
“THANKYOU SO MUCH FOR VIDEO. YOU ARE CORRECT, IF WE WANT GROWTH, LITTLE INVESTMENT IS NEEDED TO LEARN THINGS PROPERLY.”
“CA course quality hasn't decreased; students have reduced their quality. That's why they think it's dead. I've seen many experienced CAs earning in crores.”
“Top MBA colleges take good communicators only, but CA professional gives the chance to a below-average student for a good life. No IIT, IIM, NEET, etc., provides this opportunity to average or below-average people.”
“Best way of articulating - Thanks, Tushar. Keep Going, I am also Ex-4.”
“Conclusion: Yes, you will earn money only if you work hard, even in CA, be exceptional.”
“6 lakh is not that low for a first job, bro.”
1 likes
“Sir, thank you for your correct guidance.”
1 likes
“You are very right.”
2 likes
“It's good to give 50,000 to 3 qualified instead of one getting 1,50,000 per month. It's good for society if more people get jobs.”
2 likes
“I agree with you, ICAI should take a stand for us.”
1 likes
What could be better
“That's why every CA is going to run a coaching mafia.”
22 likes
“I've seen people with exceptional practical knowledge failing, but theoretical students passing exams easily.”
17 likes
“Why do CA teachers and influencers say 'become a CA and life is set'? Not everyone's life is set. CA campus placements are only 20%, despite what videos say.”
13 likes
“ICAI expects everyone to maintain professional excellence, except for themselves.”
8 likes
“ICAI's approach is horrible. They want us to mug things like due dates and slab rates, which AI or Google can answer, instead of teaching how to use tax law books.”
6 likes
“CA syllabus is obsolete. No proper revision, just shuffling chapters. CA Inter has no IT or Management subjects, and no proper IT skills.”
5 likes
“This course is ruined, don't pursue CA anymore; it will have no value.”
5 likes
“Everyone asks for US GAAP, UK GAAP, IFRS experience, and hands-on ERP software experience, but these are not in the CA syllabus. How can freshers have this experience?”
4 likes
“You are a CA promoting CA. CA has been degrading by ICAI and CAs themselves who treat CA students as their personal helpers.”