Teacher Mirrorteachermirror
New York Vocal Coaching

New York Vocal Coaching

Education
4.1
Great

59 comments

5-star
4-star
3-star
2-star
1-star

Review summary

Based on 59 comments, created with AI

Students overwhelmingly praise this teacher's study material, teaching quality, teacher's experience. Many students highlight rich, diverse, and analytical, covering a wide range o...

What students talk about most

Study Material

The study material is highly engaging, diverse, and provides insightful analysis of various artists ...

Teaching Quality

The teacher excels at providing deep, analytical insights into vocal techniques and artist craftsman...

Teacher's Experience

The teacher exhibits broad and deep knowledge of vocal techniques and music analysis, indicating sig...

Fees vs Value

While there are no direct comments on fees, the overwhelmingly positive feedback on the quality of i...

Evaluation breakdown

Teaching Quality4.0
Provides deep pedagogical insights into vocal techniques (e.g., breathy mix, chest voice, head voice flips).
Offers detailed, insightful analysis of artist craftsmanship and vocal control (e.g., Billie Eilish's accuracy, Taylor Swift's perceived ease vs. actual difficulty).
Fosters appreciation for authentic singing and critical listening, rejecting over-tuning.
Potentially provides unhealthy or inaccurate vocal health advice regarding nodules and whistle register.
Teacher's Experience4.0
Demonstrates extensive knowledge across various vocal techniques and artists (e.g., Billie Eilish, Kesha, Mariah, Taylor Swift, Jack White).
Capable of nuanced music analysis and understanding of vocal pedagogy.
The vocal health advice given raises questions about the completeness or accuracy of their expertise in critical areas.
Study Material4.5
Rich, diverse, and analytical, covering a wide range of artists and vocal techniques with impactful examples.
Introduces students to hidden talents and provides historical/cultural context for artists.
Focuses on real-world vocal production, effort, and creativity (e.g., Billie Eilish's craftsmanship, Jack White's spontaneity).
Some specific artist choices (e.g., Beyonce) might not resonate with all students.
Doubt Support3.0
Tests & Practice3.0
Flexibility3.0
Fees vs Value3.5
Strong positive feedback on content quality and insightful analysis implies good value for money.
No direct comments on fees or explicit value assessment.
Teacher Personality3.5
Appears engaging, passionate, and capable of inspiring students to appreciate complex vocal concepts.
Delivers content in a way that evokes strong emotional responses and appreciation.
Specific opinions or examples might alienate some students (e.g., 'You lost me with Beyonce').
The vocal health comment raises concerns about judgment or potentially overconfident advice.

Top Strengths

1. In-depth Vocal Analysis and Pedagogy

2. Engaging and Diverse Study Material

3. Fostering Appreciation for Vocal Craftsmanship

Areas to Improve

1. Accuracy and Safety of Vocal Health Advice

2. Broader Appeal of Artist Examples

3. Clarity on practical application and student support mechanisms

What students love

“I used to hate Billie Eilish’s songs, but learning about pedagogy made me appreciate her breathy mix and chest voice. It's fascinating and challenging to achieve.”

29 likes

“What fascinates me about Billie Eilish isn’t her range, but how she uses vocal textures, flips flawlessly between chest and head voice, and uses a buttery tone to paint imagination.”

19 likes

“Kesha is a surprisingly talented singer. I was blown away when I heard her doing a whistle voice in 'Praying'.”

9 likes

“Mariah immediately brought tears to my eyes & chills all over my body just listening to those samples. Absolutely mind-blowing.”

5 likes

“The 'Shake It Off' performance is an 'easy' song for Taylor Swift, yet it's still difficult for the majority of other singers, which is crazy.”

3 likes

“I admire Billie Eilish for her 'craftsmanship' – rejecting pitch correction and doing multiple takes. Singing quietly without losing pitch accuracy requires immense control.”

1 likes

“What a wonderful analysis. Thank you guys!”

“Love this and Justin's part is pure gold! I'm sick of hearing everything tuned, even 'live' setups are tuned or playback these days.”

“Jack White is incredible with his ad-libbing and creativity. He never plays or sings a song the same way live, feeling it out in the moment for pure spontaneity.”

“Mariah is one of the most influential, versatile, and important voices of all time, whose contributions far outweigh any bad performance.”

What could be better

“You lost me with Beyonce.”

1 likes

“She said the reason she can hit the whistle register is because of nodules on her vocal chords and that she learned to sing around them! That’s not healthy at all!”

Had a class with New York Vocal Coaching?