Nicholas Ma

Education

4.3

Great

129 comments

5-star

4-star

3-star

2-star

1-star

Review summary

Based on 129 comments, created with AI

Students overwhelmingly praise this teacher's teacher's experience, teaching quality, teacher personality. Many students highlight highly skillful composer and pianist (implied by ...

What students talk about most

Teacher's Experience

Nicholas Ma possesses a high level of expertise and skill in music composition and performance, evid...

Teaching Quality

Nicholas Ma demonstrates exceptional skill in musical composition and execution, creating captivatin...

Teacher Personality

Nicholas Ma's personality is perceived as authentic and 'human,' which resonates positively with som...

Study Material

The core musical compositions and ideas presented are highly engaging, challenging, and inspiring. H...

Evaluation breakdown

Teaching Quality3.5

Brilliantly composed and beautifully executed

Skillful composition and great layering of musical textures

Captivating, thrilling, and innovative use of technology (ChatGPT lyrics)

Evokes strong emotions and inspires imitation

Explanations are difficult to understand for many students (e.g., 'only understood about 25%', 'can’t understand shit')

Distracting visuals (Subway Surfers, Minecraft parkour) cover explanations

Modern teaching style is not preferred by all ('prefer the old slow dry way of explaining')

Teacher's Experience4.5

Highly skillful composer and pianist (implied by 'terrific pianist' and 'skillful composition')

Graduation indicates formal expertise and training

Serves as an inspiration and role model for aspiring musicians ('I sometimes imitate you')

Study Material3.0

Core compositions are highly engaging, challenging, and captivating

Material is described as 'a very interesting challenge' and 'a real challenge to all but the top choirs'

Accompanying visuals (Subway Surfers, Minecraft parkour) are highly distracting

Use of Gen-Z/Alpha slangs makes material inaccessible and frustrating for some

Doubt Support3.0

Tests & Practice3.0

Compositions themselves are described as challenging and suitable for advanced practice

Flexibility2.5

Lack of alternative teaching styles for students who prefer traditional explanations ('I prefer the old slow dry way of explaining')

Fees vs Value3.0

Teacher Personality3.5

Perceived as authentic and having a 'human touch' in compositions and arrangements

Use of Gen-Z/Alpha slangs is off-putting and frustrating for some students

Top Strengths

1. Exceptional Compositional Skill

2. Innovative and Captivating Material

3. Inspiring Role Model

Areas to Improve

1. Clarity and Accessibility of Explanations

2. Presentation Style (reduce distractions)

3. Adaptability to Diverse Learning Styles

What students love

“Brilliantly composed and beautifully executed. A very interesting challenge to work with, I'm sure.”

33 likes

“This is a beautifully written piece with very skillful composition. Congratulations on your graduation, and I'm sure you'll become an even more terrific pianist!”

18 likes

“Awesome piece! Great layering of musical textures and lines.”

17 likes

“Your music always makes me feel... I felt the turbulence that comes at the meeting of art and technology and the subtle human touches.”

13 likes

“Awesome! I get Debussy and Ravel (and a bit of Chopin's Aeolian Harp etude) atmosphere from this piece. Thank you for sharing!”

10 likes

“This would be so interesting to sing. A real challenge to all but the top choirs. A wonderful piece of composing.”

9 likes

“Very captivating and thrilling piece! I’m so amazed at how you got ChatGPT to write such lyrics.”

7 likes

“Wonderful idea and excellent execution. Bravo!!!”

7 likes

“Your 'human touch' definitely comes through your musical composition and lyrical arrangement — wonderful piece.”

4 likes

“You compose very beautifully! I am just starting out (I am 15) and I sometimes imitate you.”

3 likes

What could be better

“BRO THAT SUBWAY SURFERS IS TOO DISTRACTING OML💔😔🫩🫩”

1 likes

“I have a music degree and only understood about 25% of this.”

1 likes

“I only understood until modulation, bro, what?”

“Can you stop covering the explanations with Minecraft parkour for a sec? I gotta study for my upcoming Music exam, dude.”

“I prefer the old slow dry way of explaining.”

“As a Gen Z, I can’t understand shit.”

“As a student who had to use this video for an assignment... My head hurts, and yes, I am that student who HATES the Gen-Z/Alpha slangs...”

Had a class with Nicholas Ma?