Punch
72 comments
Review summary
Based on 72 comments, created with AI
Students overwhelmingly praise this teacher's teaching quality, teacher's experience, study material. Many students highlight excellent trading lessons, mind-blowing video, opened ...
What students talk about most
Evaluation breakdown
Top Strengths
1. Transformative Trading Education (Mindset & Strategy)
2. Clear Explanation of Complex Trading Concepts
3. Focus on Risk Management and Discipline
Areas to Improve
1. Customer Service and Platform Reliability
2. Addressing Allegations of Scam/Fund Issues
3. Improving Software Functionality (e.g., browser-based, stop-loss)
What students love
“Excellent trading lessons. Thank you for giving your valuable time in teaching us these beautiful lessons of trading.”
1 likes
“This is a mind-blowing video. It has opened my closed doors of the brain and given a clear vision of taking or not taking a trade. It will definitely change my trading journey.”
1 likes
“Best YouTube channel to learn about the stock market and trading. Keep continuing this series, sir.”
1 likes
“This is a new thing I learned today. Thank you, sir.”
1 likes
“As a student following imbalance trading, this episode was a great validation. The core message: Trade for LOSS, stop overtrading, wait for the right setup.”
“From sir, I learned how trading really works. Now I chase for my setup, not a trade. If a setup forms, I risk 1% and aim for 4%+ profit. This is trading.”
“I'm a crypto trader. What you said about volume and imbalance applies to crypto too. Big price movements come after volume. Very valuable video!”
“Genuine information: Trading is a game of mindset and discipline. This was the best learning for me ever.”
“Earlier, I traded for profits. Now I trade accepting losses first. My focus is mindset over emotions, institutional imbalance, and patience for perfect setups.”
“I risk 1% to make 4% — and it changed everything. Losses are small, so fear is gone. Rewards are big, so patience comes naturally. My psychology shifted.”
What could be better
“Customer service is not good; it's very bad. Please improve this first.”
1 likes
“Only story and nonsense.”
“Two days I used this Punch on my laptop, it was hanging. If their software was browser-based, it would be the best. Hope to see it on a web browser.”
“1 hour of useless talk.”
“There is no stop loss option.”
“Punch app: 50,000 added successfully, but the balance is not showing in my trading account. I can't trade with Punch. Don't use this app. Punch is a scam broker.”