Teacher Mirrorteachermirror
Saim Kushwaha [ IIT Dhanbad]

Saim Kushwaha [ IIT Dhanbad]

JEE
2.5
Poor

52 comments

5-star
4-star
3-star
2-star
1-star

Review summary

Based on 52 comments, created with AI

Students overwhelmingly praise this teacher's teacher personality, teacher's experience, doubt support. Many students highlight students address the teacher respectfully ('sir') an...

What students talk about most

Teacher Personality

The teacher appears to have an approachable and helpful personality, encouraging students to seek gu...

Teacher's Experience

The teacher's personal experience at IIT Dhanbad provides a strong foundation for his guidance. Howe...

Doubt Support

While students actively seek clarification and some find their doubts resolved, a significant portio...

Fees vs Value

The value of the guidance is highly variable; it is appreciated when accurate but severely compromis...

Evaluation breakdown

Teaching Quality2.0
Videos are described as 'informative' and 'very helpful' by some students.
Helped clarify confusion regarding the MIS Form for some students.
Information provided in videos is sometimes inaccurate or incomplete (e.g., missing college mail ID, details not matching official documents).
Students report issues with non-existent MIS slips despite being told they are available.
Technical issue reported: 'Voice non sync'.
Teacher's Experience3.0
Teacher's background from IIT Dhanbad lends credibility to his guidance on the institution.
Students approach him with specific queries about IIT Dhanbad programs and placements, indicating trust in his experience.
The inaccuracies in information suggest a potential lack of up-to-date knowledge on current administrative processes at IIT Dhanbad.
Study Material2.0
The videos serve as a form of 'study material' or guidance, aiming to inform students about crucial admission processes.
The primary 'material' (information in videos) is frequently inaccurate, leading to confusion and frustration among students.
Students report that details mentioned in videos do not match official documents or website options.
Doubt Support2.5
Students feel comfortable asking a wide range of questions in the comments section.
Some comments indicate that initial confusion was cleared by the videos.
Many negative comments are essentially unresolved doubts or complaints about misleading information, indicating that the initial guidance caused more confusion.
Students are left asking 'what to do' when information provided doesn't match reality.
Tests & Practice1.0
No comments or information provided relate to JEE tests, practice, or academic preparation.
Flexibility2.0
The video format offers inherent flexibility for students to access information at their convenience.
The recurring issues with outdated or incorrect information suggest a lack of flexibility or responsiveness in keeping the guidance current with real-time changes in official processes.
Students report not receiving slips by deadlines mentioned, indicating a lack of timely updates.
Fees vs Value2.5
When the information is accurate and helpful, students perceive good value, expressing gratitude for clarity.
The frequent inaccuracies and discrepancies significantly diminish the value of the guidance, potentially causing more stress and confusion than help.
Misleading information during critical admission periods can have negative consequences for students.
Teacher Personality3.5
Students address the teacher respectfully ('Sir') and sometimes informally ('brother'), suggesting an approachable and friendly demeanor.
The willingness of students to ask questions indicates they feel comfortable interacting with him.
While not directly criticizing his personality, the widespread frustration with inaccurate information could indirectly reflect on his diligence or attention to detail in preparing content.

Top Strengths

1. Approachable and helpful demeanor

2. Credibility from IIT Dhanbad background

3. Intent to provide useful guidance

Areas to Improve

1. Accuracy and timeliness of information provided in videos

2. Technical quality of video production (e.g., voice sync)

3. Responsiveness to official updates and student queries regarding discrepancies

What students love

“Thank you so much Sir. I got M.Tech in Water Resources Engineering at IIT ISM Dhanbad. I have a query regarding when the branch started and placements. Is the original degree mandatory for DV?”

1 likes

“For those asking about essential daily needs for DV: just pack clothes and essential documents. Hostel rooms have 2 chairs and 2 beds. Everything else like buckets, mugs, locks, study tables, bed sheets, pillows, mattresses, etc., can be bought right outside the hostel.”

“So informative video, very helpful... Thank you brother...”

“For IIT Dhanbad students, hostels are allotted. M.Tech 1st year will get Sapphire and B.Tech 1st year will get Jasper hostel. Room number and roommate details will be given on DV day.”

“Thank you Sir for this video, it's really helpful. I was confused about the MIS Form but now it's clear that it will come 1 week before DV day, right?”

“Thank you sir”

“Sir, for academic things, thank you very much. But please share some essential or important things to bring when coming here, because I am so confused about missing something. Please share what was important for you when you went there.”

“Mis slip is available. Now you can download it by logging into your account.”

“Hello sir... I have qualified GATE. I want to pursue M.Tech in Mining Engineering from IIT Dhanbad. Please can you discuss how IIT Dhanbad is for M.Tech in Mining and how are the placements for mining engineering?”

“For any doubts regarding MIS form or documents, watch this video: https://youtu.be/vi5dmKdoHQM”

What could be better

“Sir, I just downloaded my MIS slip but there is no college mail ID or anything. There is only one new thing, i.e., hostel name, and all other things are the same. There is no college mail ID or other details that you mentioned in your video. Please tell us how we can coordinate for the bus and other things.”

“Sir, I just got a mail to download my MIS slip but there is no MIS slip 😥”

“ISM Dhanbad sent a mail with a link for the MIS slip and academic calendar, but after logging in, no link for the MIS slip is showing. Is this the case for everyone??”

“Sir, I was called for DV on the 21st, but I haven't received the MIS registration slip yet. Sir, what to do..”

“Voice non sync”

“After the payment of admission fee for M.Tech Structural Engineering, no option is available for MIS Registration Slip on the website. What to do?”

Had a class with Saim Kushwaha [ IIT Dhanbad]?